On-the-scene management: When an athlete’s knee is injured during play, the main objective of an exam on the field is to assess the gross neurovascular status of the leg, the stability of the knee, and any deformities that may indicate a fracture. Splinting is not necessary if the knee is stable. A more thorough evaluation and initial treatment of the injury can follow on the sidelines and in the locker room. Rapid swelling and suspected neurovascular injury are among the indications for immediate referral to an orthopedist.
The first minutes after an athlete sustains a knee injury can provide valuable information that is hard to obtain later. After 10-15 minutes, swelling, muscle spasm, and pain may become significant, and they increase overnight, making examination of the knee more and more difficult. Yet the athlete typically has to be removed from the field before being examined thoroughly.* The initial examination, then, is aimed primarily at determining how best to move the patient to a quieter spot for a more thorough examination and initial treatment of the injury.
* This discussion will consider knee injuries primarily in the context of football since that is a sport in which they are particularly common. The same principles can be applied to other sports as well, however.
This initial assessment focuses more on stability than on the location and degree of tenderness or pain because these factors can be misleading. Many major knee injuries do not cause pain until the next day. In addition, stability is particularly difficult to assess once the knee has begun to swell.
Before moving the athlete, check the neurologic function and vascular status of the leg, and palpate the knee to detect false motion or gross deformities. If the patient cannot fully extend the knee immediately following injury, he or she may have a displaced meniscal tear. Do not attempt to unlock a locked knee on the field. Stretcher transfer is not necessary in the absence of obvious fracture or deformity. Perform a brief, on-the-spot ligament exam when there is no obvious fracture.
The exam can be done quickly, using the Lachman test, a posterior drawer test at 90 degrees of flexion, and varus and valgus stress tests (see “Physical examination,’ page 36). For a quick evaluation of the collateral ligaments, apply valgus and varus stress to the knee. If you find excessive laxity in either direction, apply a splint to support the unstable joint. If you decide a stretcher is unnecessary, the athlete can hop off the field on the leg, letting the injured leg dangle, with a person on either side supporting him under the shoulders. Whether the knee is stable or unstable, no weight bearing is permitted until you do a more complete exam at the sidelines and later in the locker room.
As part of the sidelines evaluation, take a more detailed history and perform a more thorough exam with an eye to determining whether the athlete can return to play. Keep him out of the game if he:
Heard a “pop’ or felt the knee give way at the time of injury
Cannot bear weight on the leg
Cannot move the leg
Cannot run or change direction
Has an unstable knee, abnormal motion, or immediate swelling
Says the knee is painful
The locker room allows for a quiet evaluation, away from the scrutiny of coaches and other players. Proceed with a complete history and knee exam as you would in your office (see “Initial impressions in the office,’ right, and “Physical examination,’ page 36).
Immediate treatment at the sidelines or in the locker room involves compression, elevation, and application of ice. Wrap the knee with an elastic bandage (Ace), and apply ice immediately. These measures minimize bleeding and swelling within the joint. Use a knee immobilizer if you have one available. Splinting is necessary for very painful injuries and for unstable ligaments and fractures.
Rapid swelling of the knee–a definite sign of hemarthrosis–a locked knee, ligament instability, and suspected neurovascular injury all necessitate immediate referral to an orthopedic surgeon. Knee dislocation and multiple ligament injuries are often associated with damage to the popliteal artery, personeal nerve, or posterior tibial nerve. Do a more thorough evaluation of nerve function on the sidelines or in the locker room by checking motor control, sensation, and pedal pulses. Pulses usually stay normal for a few hours postinjury.
